In New Jersey, a personal injury lawyer is paid a percentage of the money recovered for you, and only if money is recovered. You pay nothing to start. A state court rule caps the percentage at 33⅓% of the first $750,000 of your net recovery, with lower rates on amounts above that.
Birkhold & Maider, a personal injury firm in Montclair serving North Jersey, works on contingency. There is no upfront cost, and you pay no attorney fee unless we recover money for you. Your case evaluation is free, in English or Spanish.
If you are missing work, watching medical bills pile up, and fielding calls from an insurance adjuster, worrying about the cost of a lawyer is completely reasonable. Below, we walk through the exact math: the fee schedule, the order money comes out of a settlement, how expenses and medical liens work, and a real breakdown from one of our cases.
What is a contingency fee?
A contingency fee is a lawyer’s fee that depends on the outcome of your case. If your case brings in money through a settlement or a verdict, the lawyer receives an agreed percentage of that recovery. If it brings in nothing, there is no attorney fee.
That arrangement does three practical things for you:
- No money up front. You do not pay a retainer, and you will not get hourly bills while you are out of work.
- We advance the case expenses. Medical records, filing fees, and expert witnesses cost money long before a case resolves. Our firm pays those costs as they come up.
- Our interests match yours. Because we are paid from the same recovery you are, a better outcome for you is a better outcome for us.
New Jersey also builds in clear legal protections for clients. Under Court Rule 1:21-7, a lawyer must tell you that you have the right to hire them on an hourly basis before you agree to a contingency fee. The fee agreement must be in writing and signed by both of you, and you get to keep a signed copy. When the case ends with a recovery, your lawyer must give you a signed closing statement showing every dollar in and out. The New Jersey Supreme Court publishes the rule’s history and official comment in its Notice to the Bar.
What percentage do personal injury lawyers take in New Jersey?
New Jersey lawyers can take no more than 33⅓% of the first $750,000, and less on amounts above that. Many websites quote national ranges of “33 to 45 percent,” but those numbers do not apply here. In New Jersey, personal injury contingency fees are strictly limited by Rule 1:21-7(c), which sets these maximums for injury cases:
| Portion of net recovery | Maximum contingency fee |
|---|---|
| First $750,000 | 33⅓% |
| Next $750,000 | 30% |
| Next $750,000 | 25% |
| Next $750,000 | 20% |
| Amount above $3 million | Determined by the court upon application |
As the table shows, the maximum percentage drops at each $750,000 tier, and any fee on a recovery above $3 million requires a judge’s approval. For New Jersey personal injury cases, we typically follow this schedule. Two details matter even more than the percentages themselves.
Each rate applies only to its own slice. A larger recovery does not push the entire amount into a new rate. It works like income tax brackets: the first $750,000 is capped at 33⅓%, and only the dollars above that line get the lower rate.
The fee is calculated on your net recovery. Under Rule 1:21-7(d), case expenses are subtracted from the total settlement first, and the percentage is applied to what is left. That lowers the attorney fee slightly and keeps more money in your pocket.
Here is how those tiers add up across different recovery amounts:
| Net recovery (after expenses) | Maximum fee under the rule | Fee as a share of net recovery |
|---|---|---|
| $100,000 | $33,333 | 33.3% |
| $750,000 | $250,000 | 33.3% |
| $1,000,000 | $325,000 | 32.5% |
| $1,500,000 | $475,000 | 31.7% |
| $3,000,000 | $812,500 | 27.1% |
As the net recovery grows past $750,000, the overall share going toward the attorney fee shrinks—dropping from 33.3% on $750,000 down to 27.1% on $3,000,000.
A lower cap when the client is a child
We often represent whole families injured in the same crash, including children. New Jersey rules treat children’s cases differently to protect their recovery. When the client was a minor (or mentally incapacitated) at the time the fee agreement was signed, the fee on a settlement reached before a jury is seated cannot exceed 25%. If a judge hears the case without a jury, that 25% cap applies until the plaintiff’s opening statement or the first witness testifies, whichever comes first. The 20% rate still applies to the portion between $2.25 million and $3 million.
Can a lawyer charge less than the maximum?
Yes. Rule 1:21-7(e) makes clear that this schedule sets maximum fees, and nothing stops a lawyer from charging less. The percentage in your case is whatever is written in your contract, so read that line carefully and ask questions before you sign.
How is the money divided when a case settles?
When a case settles, the funds are paid out in a set order:
- Case expenses are reimbursed. These are the out-of-pocket costs the firm advanced to build your case.
- The attorney fee is calculated on what remains. What is left after expenses is your net recovery, and the fee schedule above applies to that number.
- Liens and unpaid medical balances are paid. A lien is a legal right to be repaid out of your settlement. We negotiate these bills down before paying them (more on that below).
- The rest goes to you. You receive your share along with a signed closing statement accounting for every deduction.
One honest detail about step 3: New Jersey’s rule does not require medical liens to be subtracted before the lawyer’s fee is calculated. That means the fee is based on the recovery after case expenses, not after medical liens. That is why lien negotiation makes such a big difference in what you actually take home.
A worked example
These numbers are an illustration, not a prediction of what your case might bring. Suppose a Newark driver is rear-ended, gets treatment for several months, and settles the case for $90,000. Here is how the settlement funds would be divided step by step:
| Step | Amount |
|---|---|
| Settlement | $90,000 |
| Case expenses reimbursed | −$1,500 |
| Net recovery | $88,500 |
| Attorney fee (33⅓% of $88,500) | −$29,500 |
| Medical liens ($15,000 owed, negotiated to $9,000) | −$9,000 |
| Client receives | $50,000 |
In this example, negotiating the medical liens down from $15,000 to $9,000 puts $50,000 in the client’s hands. Without that lien reduction, the client would have taken home $44,000. Same settlement, same attorney fee, $6,000 less for you.
What are case expenses, and who pays them if there is no recovery?
Case expenses are the out-of-pocket costs required to prove your claim, and they are separate from the attorney fee. Common expenses include:
- Medical records and billing statements
- Court filing fees
- Accident investigation costs
- Deposition transcripts (a deposition is sworn testimony taken outside of court before trial)
- Expert witness fees, such as a doctor’s written report or courtroom testimony
A case that goes deep into a lawsuit with several medical experts naturally costs more than one that settles early. We pay these expenses up front so you never have to reach into your own pocket while you are recovering.
Here is where we stand if a case does not work out: if there is no recovery, you owe no attorney fee. If your case ends before trial without a recovery, we also absorb the case expenses we advanced, including records, filing fees, and expert costs.
How expenses are handled if a case goes all the way through a trial without a recovery is spelled out in your written agreement. We sit down and read through that exact clause with you, in English or Spanish, before you sign anything. You should ask any lawyer you interview the same question and make sure the answer is in writing.
What is a lien, and how does it affect what you take home?
A lien is someone else’s legal right to be paid back out of your settlement, usually because they covered your medical care while your case was pending. By law, valid liens have to be resolved before your settlement money can be released. The ones we handle most often include:
- Health insurance plans that paid accident-related bills and have a right to reimbursement under your policy.
- Medicare and Medicaid, which have strict federal and state repayment rights when they cover injury treatment.
- Workers’ compensation carriers. If you were hurt on the job and also have a claim against someone outside your company, N.J.S.A. 34:15-40 entitles the workers’ comp insurer to be paid back from your injury settlement, minus a share of your lawsuit expenses and attorney’s fee as defined by the statute. Our page on third-party claims explains how the two cases work together.
- Doctors and medical facilities holding unpaid balances for your care.
- Child support judgments. New Jersey law requires your lawyer to run a child support judgment search before releasing settlement funds, and the statute requires a certification with your date of birth and Social Security number. That requirement is one reason a law firm asks for your Social Security number.
In car crashes, your own auto policy’s personal injury protection (PIP) coverage is part of the picture as well. Our guide to New Jersey’s no-fault rules explains why your own auto insurance pays your medical bills first and how the policies interact.
How we negotiate medical bills and liens down
The headline settlement number is not the number that matters most to your life. What you actually take home is. Before we release final checks, we go back to every lienholder and medical provider to negotiate those balances down.
In practice, that means auditing and resolving claims from health insurers, Medicare, Medicaid, or workers’ compensation, and working directly with your treating doctors to reduce unpaid medical bills. Every single dollar we get taken off a lien goes straight to you, not to our firm.
A real settlement breakdown from our files
Here is an actual case from our files, with personal details removed to protect our client’s privacy:
| Settlement breakdown | Amount |
|---|---|
| Total settlement | $1,250,000.00 |
| Attorney fee and case expenses combined | −$400,297.50 |
| Health lien paid after negotiation | −$200,000.00 |
| Amount the client received | $649,702.50 |
Out of the $1,250,000 settlement, the client took home $649,702.50 after fees, expenses, and the reduced health lien were paid. The original health insurance lien was $525,000. Our attorney negotiated it down to $200,000, putting an extra $325,000 directly into the client’s pocket. If the original lien had been paid in full, the client would have received $324,702.50.
Two things stand out here. First, the attorney fee and case expenses combined came to about 32% of the total settlement, rather than a flat third, because New Jersey’s tiered schedule drops the fee to 30% on the portion above $750,000. Second, negotiating the health lien doubled what the client walked away with.
Past results do not guarantee future outcomes. Every case depends on its own facts, the severity of the injuries, and the insurance coverage available. You can review more documented outcomes on our case results page.
Workers’ compensation fees work differently
If you were hurt on the job, the tiered schedule above does not apply to your workers’ compensation claim. In a New Jersey workers’ compensation case, a workers’ compensation judge sets the attorney fee. You and your lawyer do not negotiate a percentage on your own.
Under N.J.S.A. 34:15-64, the judge may allow a reasonable fee of up to 25% of your award, and every fee must be approved by the judge before it is paid. You might still see 20% mentioned on older websites, which was the previous cap before New Jersey updated the law to 25%.
Just like a personal injury case, you pay nothing up front. And if your work injury was caused by someone outside your company, such as another driver who hit you on a delivery route or a property owner who left a job site unsafe, you may also have a separate personal injury claim that follows the standard contingency schedule. We frequently handle both claims together for the same client. Our guide comparing workers’ comp and personal injury claims walks through how each one works.
What you get for the fee
Paying a percentage makes a lot more sense when you know what is actually being taken off your plate. Once you hire us:
- The adjusters call us, not you. We notify every insurance company involved right away. You do not need to speak with an adjuster again; that part is ours to carry now.
- One attorney stays with your case from start to finish, supported by a paralegal you can call or text directly. We get back to you within 24 hours, and we call you with updates before you have to chase us down.
- We look beyond the police report to gather witness statements, video footage, and medical records that document the full picture of your injuries.
- Every settlement offer comes directly to you with a clear breakdown of what would be deducted and what you would actually take home. We never accept or turn down an offer without your informed say-so.
- We prepare your case for a courtroom in case the insurance company refuses to make a fair offer. Our team includes a New Jersey Supreme Court-certified civil trial attorney.
Here is the honest truth about case value: what a claim is worth comes down to how badly you were hurt and how much insurance coverage is available, and no fee structure can change those facts. What a contingency fee does is let you find out what your claim is truly worth without risking your own savings. Our guide on how a claim’s value is calculated explains those factors in detail.
Is the case evaluation really free?
Yes. Sitting down with us costs nothing, whether you decide to hire us or not. You tell us what happened, we ask a few questions about your injuries, medical care, and insurance, and we give you a plain, honest answer about whether you have a claim and what comes next. If your injuries keep you from traveling, one of our attorneys will come meet you at home or in the hospital.
We can handle that first conversation, and every step of your case afterward, in English or Spanish. Your immigration status does not affect your right to bring a personal injury or workers’ compensation claim in New Jersey.
One important note on timing: New Jersey generally gives you two years from the date of an injury to file a lawsuit. That deadline is not a reason to rush into hiring someone today, though it is a good reason to get clear answers while evidence is still easy to gather and all your options are open.
Tell Us What Happened. Call 973-319-7795 or send us a message for a free case evaluation in English or Spanish. Our office is at 7 North Mountain Avenue in Montclair, and we represent injured people across Essex, Passaic, Bergen, Hudson, Union, Morris, and Middlesex counties.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much do personal injury lawyers charge in New Jersey?
New Jersey personal injury lawyers charge a contingency fee capped by Court Rule 1:21-7 at 33⅓% of the first $750,000 of your net recovery, 30% of the next $750,000, 25% of the next $750,000, and 20% of the next $750,000. On amounts above $3 million, a judge sets a reasonable fee. You pay nothing up front, and case expenses are subtracted before the lawyer’s percentage is calculated.
How do personal injury lawyers get paid if I have no money?
They are paid out of the settlement or verdict at the end of the case, never out of your pocket along the way. The law firm pays the case expenses as they come up, and the attorney fee, expenses, and medical liens are deducted from the recovery before you receive your check and a signed closing statement.
Do I owe anything if my case does not recover money?
You owe no attorney fee if we do not recover money for you. At Birkhold & Maider, if your case ends before trial without a recovery, we also cover the case expenses we paid on your behalf. How expenses are handled if a case goes through trial is written clearly in your fee agreement, and we go over it with you before you sign.
Is the contingency fee taken before or after medical bills are paid?
Usually before. Under New Jersey’s court rule, the fee is calculated on the recovery left after case expenses are deducted, and medical liens do not have to be subtracted first. Because medical liens come out of your remaining share, negotiating them down matters: every dollar cut from a lien goes straight into your pocket.
Is the fee different for a child’s injury case?
Yes. When the injured client was a minor or mentally incapacitated when the fee agreement was signed, Rule 1:21-7 caps the attorney fee at 25% on any settlement reached before a jury is seated.
How are lawyer fees set in a New Jersey workers’ compensation case?
A workers’ compensation judge sets the fee, not the lawyer. Under N.J.S.A. 34:15-64, the judge can approve a reasonable attorney fee of up to 25% of the award, and no fee can be paid without the judge’s sign-off.
Which law firms in North Jersey take injury cases on contingency with no upfront fees?
Birkhold & Maider, located in Montclair, handles car accidents, truck accidents, slip and falls, dog bites, construction injuries, wrongful death, and other personal injury claims on contingency, with zero upfront cost and a free case evaluation. We work with clients in English and Spanish across North Jersey, including Newark, East Orange, Bloomfield, Paterson, Passaic, Jersey City, Elizabeth, and Hackensack.
¿Cuánto cobra un abogado de accidentes en Nueva Jersey?
En Nueva Jersey, un abogado de accidentes cobra un porcentaje del dinero que recupera para usted, con un límite máximo de 33⅓% sobre los primeros $750,000 de la recuperación neta, según la Regla 1:21-7 de los tribunales. Usted no paga nada por adelantado y, si no se recupera dinero, no paga honorarios de abogado. En Birkhold & Maider, en Montclair, la evaluación de su caso es gratuita y podemos llevar todo su proceso en español. Llame al 973-319-7795.

